Grief after Suicide
  • Grief After Suicide Blog
  • Personal Grief Coaching
  • Training & Presentations
  • Suggest a Story
  • Contact

WHAT EXISTS IN THE GAP BETWEEN 'FEELING' GUILTY AND 'BEING' GUILTY?

5/14/2014

1 Comment

 
In the latest post on her Speaking of Suicide blog, Stacey Freedenthal calls the self-blame experienced by survivors of suicide loss "raw, painful, even toxic" and says "it does not have to be so" -- suggesting that the suicide bereaved "can replace condemnation with compassion."

First of all, I pretty much agree with what she says about compassion. And I recommend Stacey's post to any survivor who has struggled with self-blame, for it offers a number of ideas (I had never heard of "hindsight bias") and practical suggestions (including a list of questions to consider asking yourself) that might be helpful.

But reading it also made me wonder: Is intense guilt (or self-blame) "bad" for a person? Does it need to be "fixed"?

I'm not talking about the toxic version of feeling guilty: If a person experiences such a feeling so intensely or so unendingly that he or she is debilitated by it, then of course, it must be ameliorated even if it requires professional help.

But there is something normal and perhaps even necessary about feeling guilty (I'm not saying normal and necessary for everyone, for some survivors do not struggle with guilt). In many instances, however, I believe feeling guilty provides a starting place for figuring out one's true relationship to what happened. Again, please don't misunderstand: "feeling" guilty and "being" guilty are two different things, and that's really my point.

Perhaps people's struggle to reconcile the difference between what they feel and what they are actually responsible for is an important struggle for them to experience. They certainly need the support of others to help them bear their pain, but I don't think they benefit from people trying to talk them out of feeling guilty or explaining it away (people who are trying to help the bereaved sometimes do the latter because they, the helpers, can't bear to witness such pain, but that's another topic).

Perhaps the question isn't even, "Am I guilty or not?" or "Am I to blame or not?" The question might be more like, "What forces and facts exist in the gap between how I feel and what actually happened?" There are probably a hundred versions of that question -- and as many answers as there are survivors of suicide loss, for each person's experience is unique -- but people must ask their own version of the question and answer it in their own way, so they can discover and give voice to their own reality.
1 Comment
Cica
9/23/2014 11:09:50 am

I think about it everyday. That morning, waking up to his beautiful smile, asking him what wanted for breakfast. Making coffee and starting breakfast, just our morning routine. He sent me a text and a picture of us, telling in all caps he loved me. He even came into the kitchen to make sure I'd gotten it. I should have known then, but I didn't. That was 7:57 am, seconds later I heard the shot. Our lives ended that day and I don't know that I'll ever forgive myself. I am in therapy. Somedays I think I better and somedays I think I'm worse. But thank you for the kind words. It's good to know that it could be possible to forgive myself one day.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    FREE NEWSLETTER
    BLOG HOME PAGE
    • "After a Suicide" Resources 
    • Directory of Survivor Support Groups


    Categories

    All
    Advocacy & Policy
    Announcements
    Black Community
    Children's Grief
    Community Support
    Death Of A Child
    Death Of A Friend
    Death Of A Parent
    Death Of A Sibling
    Death Of A Spouse
    Depression & Grief
    Experts On Grief
    First Responders
    FJC's Journal
    Grief And Communities
    Health & Grief
    Helping Others
    Holidays
    Men's Grief
    Military
    National Guidelines
    Peer Support
    Programs And Services
    Research
    Spirituality & Grief
    Suicide Prevention
    Support Groups
    Survivor Outlook
    Survivor Resources
    Survivor Showcase
    Survivor Stories
    Taking Action
    Trauma

    Grief after Suicide posts are by Franklin Cook (unless noted). Learn more about Franklin's work in suicide grief support.
    Blogs on Suicide Grief
    • Alliance of Hope
    • Healing Suicide Grief
    • Lala's Mom
    • Our Side of Suicide
    • Mary's Shortcut
    • Loss of a Child
    • Bright Shining Star
    • Speaking of Suicide
    • Everything But the Cat

    RSS Feed

    TERMS OF USE AND SERVICE
    Must be read by anyone posting any content on this website.

    © 2016 Personal Grief Coaching.
    All Rights Reserved.